對上幾個月,醫館局因幾單醫療事故, 被市民狂插, 周局長疲於奔命,為醫療失誤而頻頻出鏡解畫。香港嘅醫療係咪真係咁差呢? 我個人認為香港整體醫療服務質素,應該優勝過好多地方同國家。凡有人嘅地方,就會有失誤,唔單單係香港呢笪地方。網友黑咪因意外入咗醫院,佢喺網誌裡面,都有讚揚過屯門醫院嘅醫護人員。
回想起5年前,我的弟弟因心臟出現問題要到伊利莎伯醫院做手術。 佢細個時,完全唔知自己有先天性心瓣過長。喺13歲嗰年,有一次感冒去睇醫生, 點知檢查之後發覺心臟有問題,醫生話情況好危險, 要即時做手術,如果唔做嘅話, 要24小時搵護士睇住,因為隨時有生命危險。嗰陣時邊有錢請護士?重話要24小時添! 我家姐問醫生, 做咗手術係咪會好得番?點知醫生話成功嘅機會率係50%, 另外50%可能會變植物人。聽完醫生呢番說話之後,我細佬決定唔做,心諗過得一日贃一日,總比做植物人好得多。因為無錢,所以無好似醫生咁講,請個護士24小時睇住。
我細佬起初都好驚,佢同我講,頭嗰幾晚,每晚都唔敢瞓,驚瞓著咗唔識醒。咁就累人累物喇! 之不過過吓一日,過吓又一星期,都無事發生,佢開始無咁驚,加上身體並無感到不適,佢漸漸將呢件事忘記。
點知喺30幾年後嘅某一日,佢為咗趕巴士而跑咗幾分鐘,上車之後抖唔到氣,嗰次以為死梗,好彩之後呼吸暢順番,但唔敢再返工。返到屋企之後,雖然抖到氣,但覺得個心重係翳住翳住,無辦法,唯有卜個心臟專科醫生睇吓。
醫生診斷過佢嘅情況之後,表示情況好危急,恐怕心臟負荷唔到,變成心衰竭,即係話個心臟壞死唔可以再用,咁就麻煩,所以一定要盡快做手術。跟住寫紙介紹佢去照心臟X光,然後再將X光片交返俾佢。
我大哥喺加拿大某間醫院嘅心臟科工作。我細佬將啲底片SCAN咗之後E俾我大佬,大佬睇完之後話醫生講得無錯,細佬一定要做手術,因為佢其中一塊心瓣過長,唔可以有效防止血液倒流,導致其中一邊心臟跳動次數比正常多,日積月累,已經比正常發 大咗一倍,情況真係好危急,有機會導致心衰竭。我問大哥細佬情況嘅時候,佢沉默咗一刻,無正面回答我嘅提問,佢剩係話會替細佬祈禱。我聽完之後知道情況唔樂觀,但對真正情況完全唔暸解,當時心裡感到非常不安。
我細佬其後收到顧問醫生通知,話已經將佢啲資料送咗去伊利沙伯醫院,嗰邊醫生會排期接見我細佬。過咗唔夠二星期,伊院心臟科主診醫生話已經安排好做手術嘅日期同時間,但喺做手術之前約見佢,講解手術嘅過程同埋手術面對嘅風險,重特別交帶,叫佢帶埋至親嘅屋企人一齊出席。
嗰朝我同細佬弟婦一齊去到約見地點。由一位馬醫生接見,馬醫生大約60零歲,架著一個粗框眼鏡,國字口面,俾我一個沉實穩重嘅學者印象。佢首先指出,心臟開刀係屬於高風險手術,就算預先睇過底片,商議好晒手術過程,但到正式開刀,見到個心臟嘅時候,處理方式會因實際情況而修改。
馬醫生繼續講,手術朝早8點開始,預計約5小時完成。首先要同病人全身麻醉,然後將流經心臟嘅血液,接駁去一部機器,作為臨時心臟,維持其他器官嘅氧料供應。跟住用手術電鋸,將病人胸口中間打直鋸開,之後將胸骨用儀器左右撐開,最盡撐開到6吋。之後用針葯將心臟打停,以便進行手術。
根據病情顯示,過長嘅心瓣有3種處理方式。第1種係以動物心瓣替換;第2種用金屬片代替;第3種係將病人過長嘅部份修補,裁剪到合適為止。如果用動物心瓣替換,大約可以用7年,之後要再施手術更換。用金屬片替換可以用20年,但由於血液好容易凝結喺金屬片表面,所以要長成期服食薄血丸,平日要好小心,因為如果有損傷,傷口唔係咁易埋口。故此最好就係用番病人自己經修補嘅心瓣。
當手術完成後,要用電將心臟擊活,等心臟恢復跳動。手術之後嘅24小時係最關鍵時刻,要用機器監察住個心臟,睇吓有無滲漏,如果超過呢段時間都測唔到嘅話,手術先至叫做成功。
馬醫生將整個手術過程交代得一清二楚,我聽完之後,手心冒汗。究竟手術用邊種方式進行,最後係咪成功?真係好講運氣。之前唔怪得大哥無出過聲喇,因為佢每日見慣類似嘅手術,知道風險有幾大。我之後打電通知大哥,佢好開心知道香港醫生肯同細佬做咁嘅手術。佢話呢啲咁覆雜嘅手術,加拿大好多醫生,為咗維持一個高嘅手術成功率,唔會冒咁大嘅風險同病人做呢類手術。所以唔好成日話外國嘅月亮一定比本地圓!
幸好最後手術成功,我為咗感謝醫護人員付出嘅努力,寫咗一封信讚揚各有份參與嘅醫生。
Dear Sirs,
It happened on 2-8-2007. I looked at the wall-mounted clock incessantly through out the period from 8:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. while I was working in my office. Time moved slowly by. I was anxious at that critical moment because my younger brother was having a 6-hour heart surgery that morning. His situation was getting worse recently and his circumstances were overwhelming. Surgery was unavoidable as advised by a heart specialist.
While we were waiting outside ward H7 that morning for the surgery, we met Dr. Zhu who stopped and asked my brother if his wife had signed the document regarding the surgery in a concerned manner. Dr Zhu further explained to us briefly the whole process of the surgical operation. His kind and friendly approach relieved our worries and anxieties and directly strengthened the confidence of my brother. I was impressed by Dr Zhu who applied himself wholeheartedly to his work at all times.
Two months ago, my brother’s case was referred to Dr Ma for following up. We went to visit Dr Ma for a surgery appointment. Dr Ma explained the situation to us explicitly and the risk my brother was going to face. He also told us what they would do during the operation. We had a rough concept of the surgery and I realized it was an ordeal for my brother and our relatives. Dr Ma conveyed the message to us in a professional way. His self-assured and positive manner gave us confidence in overcoming the difficulties.
By virtue of their marvelous techniques and conscientious working manner, the surgical operation of my brother was turned out to be successful. My brother made speedy progress in recuperation under the good care of all nursing staff of ward A7 & H7 after the operation.
In view of their outstanding performance, I write to express my sincere thanks to all staff of ward A7 & H7 and also the following doctors.
1 . Dr C.C.Ma
2. Dr H L Cheung
3. Dr W K Ng
4. Dr T Zhu
5. Dr W H Hui
常懷醫者父母心的醫生,就好比再生父母。
回覆刪除願有更多這些高品德的醫生、護士同護理人員,幫助病者及其家屬解決困難。
更要感謝菩薩保佑!
樹大有枯枝,我喺衙門做事,見過有盡心盡意做好自己剛位的同事,亦有部份故意將一些查詢,對巿民作出誇張及帶有威嚇性的回覆!當你曾經到過內地的醫院,就會分辨出,香港醫護人員的品德及工作態度,普遍較其他地方優勝!
刪除樹大有枯枝,現在的醫護人員大都好好!94年我在QE做個一個算係大嘅手術,令我改觀,再不是以前俾利是的時代,出院後兩個幾月去覆診,即刻買咗兩盒朱古力同兩張感謝卡送番去病房護士同醫生,感謝佢哋!
回覆刪除我相信曾經住過醫院的朋友,都同意香港醫護人員是優秀及專業的!
刪除我絶對認同香港整體醫療服務質素是好,戥你的弟弟康復感到高興!
回覆刪除可惜我不會閱讀英文讚揚信 !
信中的意思是多謝那幾位醫生及病房的護理人員,藉著他們的專業技術及愛心,我弟弟的病情才會化險為夷及能夠在短期內復原!
刪除政府醫生搵錢少, 工時長, 辛苦又受氣. 我住過院, 探過病, 覺得服務同質素真係超好. 起碼比溫哥華好.
回覆刪除加拿大醫療由政府找數, QUOTA滿咗之後,好似就無得CLAIM,所以啲醫生就話知你! 好似我細佬單CASE,大哥話响加拿大未必會做呢個咁大風險嘅手術!
刪除好多年前, 加拿大醫生罷工, 香港醫生邊會咁.
刪除相對來說,香港醫療比較世界其他地方算做好架喇!
刪除為他她們打氣!
回覆刪除我睇報紙, 間中出現家屬投訴醫療失誤,不過當我睇吓個病人,原來成八十幾歲,又係長期病患者,你估醫生真係神先咩? 但啲家屬永遠都唔會滿意,郁吓就投訴,好明顯係濫用咗呢個機制!亦俾大眾一個感覺,香港醫療失誤好嚴重!所以我覺得為佢哋打氣係有必要的!
刪除我都絕對認同香港整體醫療服務質素非常好!
回覆刪除只是有些人雞蛋裡面挑骨頭。
有好多人又煙又酒,平時一啲運動都無,百病緾身!到醫唔好嘅時候,又怪責醫療失誤!佢哋唔儉討一吓自己,點解平時唔注意健康?到有病嘅時候,就將責任推俾醫護人員!
刪除有時就醫都好講彩數, 早前個舊同學老豆入左院, 次次去醫院都見唔到醫生, 問姑娘病情, 姑娘又話問醫生, 留口訊叫個醫生打電話畀佢, 等極都冇打來, 攪到屋企人都唔知個病人情況係點.
回覆刪除我自己前幾年入醫院做個小手術, 麻醉師前一日向我講解全身麻醉同局部麻醉的分別, 我聽完後唔想全身麻醉, 揀局部麻醉. 但係問係一回事, 真係做手術時, 全部醫護用人海戰術, 施加壓力, 逐個來問我係唔係全身麻醉. 問到我發火, 最後有個應該係護士中較高級的又問我係唔全身麻醉, 我話家陣好似係你地想我做全身麻醉咁喎. 咁樣先至停左呢D壓力迫害. 我咁肯定佢地係有意圖咁做, 因為個醫生入來時, 個麻師同佢講: 未得住, 要等多十分鐘, by patient's request, 做區域麻醉. 咁個醫生又走返出去. 我估呢班友為左方便快捷, 就焗我全身麻醉, 咁就可以準時出去食lunch.
呢樣就唔清楚喇!究竟局部麻醉同全身麻醉係咪應該睇手術是否需要?還是好像早餐般,有A餐同B餐,只係價錢上有分別呢?你講得啱,手術好講彩數,當時QE有三組心臟科醫生,我細佬個組嘅成功率較其他兩組高!
刪除有你呢封感謝信,就等同為醫護人員打左枝強心針呀!
回覆刪除我覺做得好要讚,做得唔好就要彈,但切忌感情用事,間中睇到有家屬投訴醫療失誤,但睇番個病人,八十幾歲,又係長期病患者,你估醫生係神仙咩?個個都救得生!
刪除HI~philip~hk醫療簡直是~世上少有~講真醫療歸政府國家都是~羊毛出在羊身上~,新加坡醫療很成功,不過要~公平分擔~絕不好彩
回覆刪除hk醫療是~港英政府~造成,好醜就要看~見(人)見智了,如果~長此好下去~就要看hk人......了,老美醫療也不想說,不如謂下~醫療人員&病人~......點滴好了,我家大少成功入了醫學院了........真是一匹有~咁長咁......~總之老美訓練一個醫生是~不惜$$$$$$$~,唉~最近maggie給那個睡眠牙醫......激到跳舞,他真是~中東死衰公~如果我英文好呢,一定在網上..........,政府用$$$$$$$$訓練這種~費醫~真寃枉,西醫真是~一言堂主~不接受病人一點.......,吓~連大少未做醫生已經站在他~那邊~幸好他尊重我.......才接受我的~反駁~文中...........有機會再在我blog上分享,很認同您大哥......外國觀點,我也有一位朋友做您弟弟手術,真是~嚇餐死~
Hi! 您好! 近況好嗎? 香港醫療算好架喇,起碼唔會見到錢先至醫你! 醫生除咗醫術要好之外,醫德都好重要!你個BLOG開咗未? 記得通知聲!
刪除聽完你咁講,醫院手術成功率低,是因為做得太多高風險手術。
回覆刪除除咗醫生之外,律師都一樣,假如勝算低嘅官司,出名律師未必會接,無謂拖低勝出率!
刪除